We Tested Top 3 Lemlist Alternatives For Cold Outreach: Here's Our Findings

By
Lukas Makšimas
August 6, 2024
5 min read
Table of contents
Subscribe for newsletter
AI Agent Frank
Auto-pilot

If you're like me, you've probably spent a fair amount of time trying to perfect your cold outreach. 

Maybe you've been using Lemlist and you're starting to wonder if there are better tools out there. 

Or perhaps you're just curious about what other options exist. 

Either way, this blog is for you.

Cold outreach can be a game-changer for growing your business, but finding the right tool can be a bit of a challenge. Lemlist is a popular choice, but is it really the best fit for your needs?

That's what I wanted to find out. So, I tested three of the best Lemlist alternatives – Salesforge, Outreachbin, and Instantly. And I'm here to share what I learned.

These tools might just address some of the frustrations you’ve had with Lemlist. They offer different features and benefits that could make your outreach more effective and your life a little easier.

I know what you might be thinking: “Great, another tool review. Just what I needed.” But stick with me – I’m going to break down my experience with each tool, so you don’t have to go through trial and error yourself.

Here’s what we’ll cover:

  • Why you might be looking for Lemlist alternatives: Maybe Lemlist isn’t quite cutting it for you anymore.

  • A detailed look at Salesforge, Outreach Bin, and Instantly: What makes these tools stand out?

  • Comparison of features, pricing, and user experiences: Which tool offers the best bang for your buck?

  • My final thoughts: Which tool might be the best fit for different scenarios?

  • Pros and cons of each tool: So you can make an informed decision.

Let’s dive in and find the best Lemlist alternatives for your cold outreach needs.

What is Lemlist?

Lemlist is an email outreach and automation tool designed to enhance email campaigns through personalization and automation.

Lemlist-homepage
This image shows the homepage of Lemlist

Key Features of Lemlist:

  • Email Outreach and Automation: Simplifies cold emailing, though automation can feel rigid.

  • Email Warm-Up (Lemwarm): Gradually warms up email accounts to improve deliverability, though it can be slow.

  • Cold Email Templates and Personalization: Easy to use but may require tweaks.

  • Campaign Management and Sequences: Intuitive and efficient.

  • Video Prospecting and Personalized Images: Boosts engagement significantly.

Lemlist Pricing 

Lemlist offers four pricing plans with increasing levels of features and credits for email finding and verification. 

The plans cater to a range of needs, from basic email campaigns to comprehensive multichannel outreach and team management. 

Lemlist-pricing
This image shows the pricing of Lemlist

  1. Email Starter Plan
    • Monthly: $39 per user/month
    • Quarterly: $35 per user/month
    • Annually: $32 per user/month
    • Features:
      • Unlimited campaigns
      • Customizable email campaigns
      • 450M+ leads database
      • AI-generated sequences
      • Email finder + verifier (750 credits/month)
      • Custom reports & analytics
      • Personalized booking page

  1. Email Pro Plan
    • Monthly: $69 per user/month
    • Quarterly: $62 per user/month
    • Annually: $55 per user/month
    • Features:
      • All Email Starter features
      • Email finder + verifier (1,000 credits/month)
      • Email warm-up and deliverability booster
      • CRM integrations
      • Custom image personalization
      • Campaign A/B tests
      • Inbox rotation

  1. Multichannel Expert Plan
    • Monthly: $99 per user/month
    • Quarterly: $89 per user/month
    • Annually: $79 per user/month
    • Features:
      • All Email Pro features
      • Email finder + verifier (1,500 credits/month)
      • LinkedIn prospection
      • LinkedIn voice notes
      • Cold calling prospection with Aircall
      • Custom landing pages

  1. Outreach Scale Plan
    • Monthly: $159 per user/month
    • Quarterly: $144 per user/month
    • Annually: $129 per user/month
    • Features:
      • All Multichannel Expert features
      • Email finder + verifier (2,500 credits/month)
      • Dedicated account manager (4+ seats)

The plans also offer discounts for quarterly and annual billing, making it more cost-effective for long-term commitments.

Why Should You Consider Lemlist Alternatives?

After analyzing the user reviews, the following points are identified as the most frequently mentioned complaints and disliked features:

  1. Bug Issues
    • Repeated reports of the system being buggy, especially creating duplicates in CRM systems when bots open emails.
Lemlist-G2-review
This image shows the user review of Lemlist in G2
  1. Lack of Pipeline Feature
    • Multiple users noted the absence of a pipeline feature, which is crucial for managing sales processes.

  1. DNS Settings Delay
    • Users frequently mentioned the long wait time (up to 72 hours) for changes in DNS settings to take effect.

  2. Reporting and Analytics
    • Numerous complaints about the reporting functionality being non-intuitive and difficult to understand.
Lemlist-G2-review
This image shows the user review of Lemlist in G2
  1. Editing Campaigns
    • Common dissatisfaction with the limited ability to edit campaigns once they are live or add steps to existing sequences.
Lemlist-G2-review
This image shows the user review of Lemlist in G2
Lemlist-G2-review
This image shows the user review of Lemlist in G2
  1. Cost and Credits
    • High costs associated with email enrichment and connecting multiple email accounts were frequently criticized.
Lemlist-G2-review
This image shows the user review of Lemlist in G2
Lemlist-G2-review
This image shows the user review of Lemlist in G2
  1. LinkedIn Integration
    • Several users were disappointed with the accuracy of the LinkedIn integration and the lack of official partnership.
Lemlist-G2-review
This image shows the user review of Lemlist in G2
  1. Interface and User Experience
    • Many users found the interface not user-friendly, with settings and integrations feeling hidden.

If you're interested in learning more about Lemlist, check out my comprehensive Lemlist review

Whether you're looking for a detailed breakdown of its features or an analysis of its pricing plans, I've got you covered.

What are the Criteria for Selecting Lemlist Alternatives?

When evaluating alternatives to Lemlist, focus on these key criteria to ensure the best fit for your email outreach needs:

  1. Features
    • Advanced Automation: Comprehensive email automation, including follow-ups and drip campaigns.
    • Personalization: Dynamic personalization options.
    • Email Warm-Up: Effective tools for improving deliverability.
    • Analytics: Robust reporting and analytics.
    • Bonus Features: Extras like video prospecting and CRM integration.

  1. Pricing
    • Competitive Plans: Good value for money with various pricing tiers.
    • Transparency: No hidden fees.
    • Flexibility: Month-to-month options and scalability.

  1. User Experience
    • Intuitive Interface: Easy to use and navigate.
    • Easy Onboarding: Smooth setup with clear instructions.
    • Efficient Management: Simple creation and tracking of campaigns.
    • Customizability: Flexible email design and sequence management.

  1. Integrations
    • CRM Compatibility: Works with popular CRM systems.
    • Marketing Tools: Integrates with other marketing tools.
    • Social Media: Supports LinkedIn and other platforms.
    • API Access: Custom API integrations.

  1. Customer Support
    • Responsive Service: Quick and helpful customer support.
    • Resources: Detailed help guides and tutorials.
    • Issue Resolution: Efficient handling of technical problems.
    • Active Community: User forums for tips and support.

These criteria will help you find a Lemlist alternative that enhances your email outreach effectively.

#1. Salesforge - Best Alternative to Lemlist For Cold Email Outreach

Salesforge is a state-of-the-art email outreach platform designed to revolutionize the way businesses conduct cold email campaigns. It offers advanced features that streamline the process, ensuring high deliverability, effective personalization, and robust email infrastructure.

Salesforge empowers sales teams to connect with prospects more efficiently and effectively, driving better engagement and conversion rates.

Salesforge-homepage
This image shows the homepage of Salesforge

Key Features of Salesforge:

1. Personalization at Scale 

Salesforge excels in providing programmatic personalization, ensuring each email feels uniquely crafted for the recipient. This feature includes:

  • Automatic Personalization: Automatically includes personalized details like LinkedIn URLs and company data in your emails.

  • Enhanced Engagement: Personalized emails help build stronger connections with prospects, increasing engagement rates.
Standard-AI-personalized-email
This image shows the Standard AI personalized email feature in Salesforge

2. Robust Email Infrastructure 

Salesforge simplifies the process of setting up and managing your email infrastructure, ensuring high deliverability rates. Key tools include:

  • Mailforge: Simplifies the setup of your cold email infrastructure in just 5 minutes, ensuring your emails have a better chance of landing in the recipient's inbox. 
Mailforge-homepage
This image shows the homepage of Mailforge
 Infraforge-homepage
This image shows the homepage of Infraforge

3. Advanced AI Capabilities 

Salesforge leverages advanced AI and machine learning to improve your email outreach strategies. Features include:

  • AI-Powered Email Writing: Generates personalized email copy quickly, saving time and effort.

  • Continuous Improvement: The AI learns which email formats get the best responses and adjusts your campaigns accordingly.
 Sequence-builder-in-Salesforge
This image shows the Sequence builder feature in Salesforge

4. Email Validation and Deliverability Tools 

Salesforge ensures your emails reach the right inboxes by providing robust validation and deliverability tools:

  • Email Validation: Validates email addresses within the platform to ensure your messages are delivered.

  • Deliverability Tools: Includes inbox rotation and domain setup guidance to maintain high deliverability rates.

5. Comprehensive Support 

Salesforge offers dedicated support to ensure you get the most out of its features:

  • Dedicated Support: Provides reliable and responsive support to quickly resolve issues.

  • Help Center: Offers resources and guidance to help you navigate and utilize the platform effectively.

How Is Salesforge Better Than Lemlist?

Here's a quick comparison between Salesforge and Lemlist:

Based on user reviews and features, here are several ways Salesforge is considered better than Lemlist:

  1. Cost Efficiency

    • Salesforge: Incredibly cost-effective, especially for small-scale campaigns. Users report paying significantly less for similar features compared to other platforms. 

    • Lemlist: Higher costs for features like email enrichment and connecting multiple email accounts.

Salesforge-G2-review
This image shows the user review of Salesforge in G2
  1. AI-Driven Content Creation

    • Salesforge: Utilizes advanced AI to craft personalized and creative email content that rivals the best sales development representatives (SDRs). AI-generated emails save time and increase engagement.
  • Lemlist: Offers personalization but lacks the advanced AI capabilities for crafting unique email content at scale.

Salesforge-G2-review
This image shows the user review of Salesforge in G2
  1. User Experience and Ease of Use

    • Salesforge: Praised for its user-friendly interface, easy setup, and intuitive design tailored by salespeople for salespeople. Provides automatic  configuration of technical settings like DMARC, DKIM, and SPF.

    • Lemlist: Users report initial setup can be challenging, and the interface is not as intuitive or user-friendly. 

  1. Customer Support

    • Salesforge: Highly regarded for responsive and helpful customer support, with many users noting the excellent service provided through platforms like Intercom.

    • Lemlist: While it offers support, some users have found it less efficient in resolving issues.

Salesforge-G2-review
This image shows the user review of Salesforge in G2
  1. Email Deliverability and Infrastructure

    • Salesforge: Strong focus on email deliverability with advanced warm-up capabilities and the ability to quickly set up mailboxes and domains.

    • Lemlist: Provides email warm-up tools but can be slow and requires consistent monitoring.
  1. Integration and Flexibility

    • Salesforge: Offers multiple integrations (e.g., Zapier), making it flexible and easy to connect with other tools.
    • Lemlist: Integrations are available but are sometimes seen as less seamless or hidden within the interface.
  1. Advanced Features

    • Salesforge: Includes powerful features such as AI-driven personalization, and robust analytics, making it a comprehensive tool for sales development and lead generation. 
    • Lemlist: While it offers robust features, it lacks some of the advanced AI capabilities and ease of use found in Salesforge.
  1. Scalability

    • Salesforge: Designed to scale efficiently with features that support rapid growth in email campaigns, infrastructure setup, and domain management.
    • Lemlist: Scaling can be more cumbersome due to higher costs and the need for more manual intervention.

Overall, Salesforge offers a more cost-effective, user-friendly, and AI-driven solution compared to Lemlist, making it a preferred choice for many users looking to optimize their cold outreach efforts.

Cons of Using Salesforge

  1. Investment: Salesforge offers competitive pricing, and although a higher initial investment is needed for high-volume operations, it sets the stage for significant returns once prospects start converting.

  2. Feature Development: While some desirable features are currently missing, Salesforge is actively developing and will release them soon.

Salesforge Pricing and Plans

Salesforge offers two primary pricing plans: Growth and Pro. 

Salesforge-pricing
This image shows the pricing of Salesforge

Each plan provides a range of features designed to cater to different business needs, particularly focusing on scalability, extensive feature sets, and cost efficiency.

Growth Plan - $96/month (Monthly Plan)

  • $80/month (Annual Plan)

Key Features:

  • Active Contacts in Sequence: 10,000
  • Emails/Month: 50,000
  • Email Validation Credits/Month: 1,000
  • Email Personalization Credits/Month: 1,000
  • Unlimited Mailboxes and Users
  • Advanced AI Model (Overdrive)
  • Primebox™ and Smart Mailbox Rotation
  • Multi-Language Sequences and A/B Testing
  • Dynamic IPs and ESP Matching (Coming Soon)
  • Personal Onboarding and Priority Support

Benefits:

  • Scalability: Suitable for larger teams and extensive outreach campaigns due to high email and contact limits.
  • Advanced Features: Offers advanced AI capabilities and dynamic features for personalized and efficient email marketing.
  • Comprehensive Support: Includes personal onboarding and priority support, ensuring smooth implementation and ongoing assistance.

Ideal For:

  • Medium to large businesses
  • Sales teams requiring extensive outreach capabilities
  • Businesses planning to scale quickly

Pro Plan - $48/month (Monthly Plan)

  • $40/month (Annual Plan)

Key Features:

  • Active Contacts in Sequence: 1,000
  • Emails/Month: 5,000
  • Email Validation Credits/Month: 100
  • Email Personalization Credits/Month: 100
  • Unlimited Mailboxes
  • Single User
  • Primebox™ and Smart Mailbox Rotation
  • Dynamic IPs
  • Live Chat Support

Benefits:

  • Affordability: Lower cost makes it accessible for smaller businesses or individual users.
  • Essential Features: Provides core functionalities necessary for effective email outreach.
  • Ease of Use: Includes live chat support for immediate assistance.

Ideal For:

  • Small businesses or startups
  • Individual sales representatives
  • Businesses with lower volume outreach needs

Comparative Analysis

  1. Scalability:
    • Growth Plan: Designed for scalability with unlimited users and high limits on emails and contacts.
    • Pro Plan: Suitable for smaller-scale operations with limits on users and outreach volume.
  2. Feature Set:
    • Growth Plan: Offers a comprehensive suite of advanced features, including AI-driven tools, multi-language sequences, and advanced analytics.
    • Pro Plan: Provides essential features for email outreach, without some of the advanced functionalities of the Growth plan.
  3. Support:
    • Growth Plan: Includes priority support and personal onboarding, ensuring high-touch assistance.
    • Pro Plan: Offers live chat support, suitable for immediate queries and basic assistance.
  4. Cost Efficiency:
    • Growth Plan: Higher initial investment but offers extensive features and scalability.
    • Pro Plan: More affordable, ideal for those with limited budgets or smaller scale needs.

Salesforge's pricing plans are designed to cater to a wide range of business needs, from small startups to large sales teams. 

The Growth plan provides robust features and scalability for businesses planning significant outreach operations, while the Pro plan offers a cost-effective solution with essential functionalities for smaller-scale needs. 

Both plans emphasize flexibility, with no extra costs for additional mailboxes, and provide valuable tools for optimizing email marketing efforts.

#2. Instantly: Lemlist Best Alternative Fo Cold Outreach

Instantly is a sales engagement and email automation platform designed to streamline and enhance cold email outreach. It provides tools and features that help businesses effectively reach their prospects and manage their email campaigns.

Instatly-homepage
This image shows the homepage of Instantly

Key Features of Instantly

  1. Email Automation
    • Automates the process of sending cold emails and follow-ups, allowing for consistent and timely outreach.
  2. Personalization
    • Supports dynamic personalization of emails, making each message appear unique and tailored to the recipient.
  3. Email Warm-Up
    • Includes an email warm-up feature that gradually increases email sending volume to improve deliverability and avoid spam filters.
  4. Campaign Management
    • Provides an intuitive dashboard for creating, managing, and tracking multiple email campaigns.
  5. A/B Testing
    • Allows users to test different versions of their emails to determine which performs better, optimizing campaign effectiveness.
  6. Analytics and Reporting
    • Offers detailed analytics and reporting tools to track the performance of email campaigns, including open rates, click-through rates, and reply rates.
  7. Integrations
    • Seamlessly integrates with popular CRM systems and other marketing tools, enabling better data management and workflow automation.
  8. Multi-Channel Outreach
    • Supports outreach through various channels, including email and social media, to create a cohesive sales strategy.

How Is Instantly Better Than Lemlist?

  1. User-Friendly Interface
    • Instantly: Highly praised for its simple and intuitive interface, making it easy for users to navigate and set up campaigns quickly.
    • Lemlist: Users often find the interface more complex and challenging to navigate.

Instantly-G2-review
This image shows the user review of Instantly in G2

  1. Effective Email Warm-Up
    • Instantly: Offers a robust email warm-up feature that enhances email deliverability and keeps emails out of spam folders with minimal effort.
    • Lemlist: While it has email warm-up capabilities, users report that it can be slower and requires more ongoing management.
  2. Comprehensive Feature Set
    • Instantly: Integrates multiple functionalities, including lead generation, email tracking, and CRM, into one platform, eliminating the need for additional tools.
    • Lemlist: Provides many features but often necessitates using other tools for a complete workflow.
Instantly-G2-review
This image shows the user review of Instantly in G2

  1. Superior Customer Support  
    • Instantly: Known for excellent customer support with quick response times and helpful assistance, making it easier for users to resolve issues.
    • Lemlist: Offers customer support, but some users experience slower response times and less consistent help.
  2. AI-Driven Personalization
    • Instantly: Utilizes advanced AI to create personalized and diverse email content, which helps avoid spam filters and improve engagement rates.
    • Lemlist: Offers personalization features, but lacks the advanced AI capabilities that make email content creation easier and more effective with Instantly.
Instantly-G2-review
This image shows the user review of Instantly in G2

These key advantages demonstrate why many users prefer Instantly over Lemlist, particularly for its ease of use, effective email warm-up, comprehensive features, superior customer support, and advanced AI-driven personalization.

Cons of Using Instantly 

  1. Pricing Concerns :
    • Relatively high cost, especially for small businesses and foreign markets.
    • Basic package limitations prompt some users to upgrade to higher-cost plans for essential features.
Instantly-G2-review
This image shows the user review of Instantly in G2
  1. Learning Curve and Setup Complexity:
    • Domain and email setup process can be intense and confusing, particularly for those not familiar with technical aspects.
    • While training is provided, it can take time to fully understand the setup.
Instantly-G2-review
This image shows the user review of Instantly in G2
  1. Limited Customization and Features in Basic Plans:
    • Limited customization options for email templates.
    • Desire for more features in the lower-tier plans.
Instantly-G2-review
This image shows the user review of Instantly in G2

  1. API and Integration Limitations:
    • Need for more developed API features.
    • Desire for additional integrations with other tools and platforms to enhance functionality.
Instantly-G2-review
This image shows the user review of Instantly in G2

Instantly Pricing and Plans

Instantly offers a variety of pricing plans designed to cater to different business needs and scales of operation. Here’s a detailed analysis of each plan:

Monthly Pricing

Instantly-pricing
This image shows the monthly pricing of Instantly
  1. Growth Plan
    • Cost: $37/month
    • Features:
      • Unlimited Email Accounts
      • Unlimited Email Warmup
      • 1,000 Uploaded Contacts
      • 5,000 Emails Monthly
      • Chat Support
    • Ideal For: Small businesses or individuals just starting with email outreach, offering essential features at a lower cost.

  1. Hypergrowth Plan
    • Cost: $97/month
    • Features:
      • Unlimited Email Accounts
      • Unlimited Email Warmup
      • 25,000 Uploaded Contacts
      • 100,000 Emails Monthly
      • Premium Live Support
    • Ideal For: Growing businesses that need higher email volumes and additional support features.

  1. Light Speed Plan
    • Cost: $358/month
    • Features:
      • Everything in Hypergrowth Plan
      • 100,000 Uploaded Contacts
      • 500,000 Emails Monthly
    • Ideal For: Large businesses or high-volume email marketers needing extensive outreach capabilities.

Yearly Pricing (Save 20%)

Instantly-pricing
This image shows the annual pricing of Instantly
  1. Growth Plan
    • Cost: $30/month (billed annually)
    • Ideal For: Cost-sensitive users who prefer annual billing to save money while still accessing essential features.

  1. Hypergrowth Plan
    • Cost: $77.6/month (billed annually)
    • Ideal For: Growing businesses looking to save costs with annual billing while accessing higher volume features.

  1. Light Speed Plan
    • Cost: $286.3/month (billed annually)
    • Ideal For: High-volume email marketers who prefer annual billing to save money while maintaining extensive outreach capabilities.

  1. Enterprise Plan
    • Cost: Custom (contact for pricing)
    • Features:
      • Everything in Hypergrowth Plan
      • 500,000+ Emails Monthly
      • 100,000+ Uploaded Contacts
      • Dedicated Account Manager
      • Shared Slack Channel
      • Private Deliverability Network
    • Ideal For: Large enterprises needing customized solutions and dedicated support for extensive email marketing operations.

Key Takeaways

  • Scalability: Instantly's pricing plans cater to different scales of operations, from small businesses to large enterprises.
  • Cost Efficiency: The yearly plans offer a 20% discount, making them cost-effective for users who prefer annual billing.
  • Feature-Rich: Each plan includes essential features like unlimited email accounts and warmup, with higher-tier plans offering significantly more email and contact capacities, along with premium support.
  • Customization: The Enterprise plan offers tailored solutions and dedicated support, making it suitable for large organizations with specific needs.

#3. Reply.io: Lemlist Best Alternative For Lead Generation

Reply.io is a comprehensive sales engagement platform designed to automate and enhance the sales process. It provides a suite of tools aimed at streamlining communication and increasing productivity for sales teams, lead generation agencies, and recruiters.

Reply.io-homepage
This image shows the homepage of Reply.io

Key Features of Reply.io

  1. Multi-Channel Outreach
    • Engage prospects through email, LinkedIn, SMS, WhatsApp, and phone calls​​.

  2. AI Capabilities (Jason AI)
    • Automates email creation, responds to prospects, and books meetings​​.

  3. Email and Phone Validation
    • Verifies email addresses and phone numbers to ensure messages reach the correct audience​​.

  4. Email Warmup
    • Gradually increases email sending volume to maintain a good sender reputation and avoid spam filters.

  5. CRM Integration and Data Enrichment
    • Seamless integration with popular CRMs and enhancement of prospect data​​.

  6. Reporting and Analytics
    • Tracks email delivery rates, response rates, and overall campaign performance​.

  7. Meeting Scheduling
    • Google Calendar integration to schedule meetings directly from the platform​.

  8. Prospecting Data
    • Access to a B2B lead database with over 140 million verified contacts, and a Chrome extension for quick email sourcing and validation​​.

  9. Cloud Calling
    • VoIP calling from the browser, including international call support, call recording, and inbound call transfer.

  10. Video Personalization
    • Integration with Vidyard GoVideo to embed personalized videos in emails and track their performance​​.

  11. Sales Task Execution
    • Automation of sales tasks such as making calls and sending LinkedIn connection requests​.

How Is Reply.io is Better Than Lemlist?

Here are some reasons where Reply.io performs better than Lemlist.

Ease of Use and Interface

  • Reply.io: Praised for its intuitive, user-friendly interface, making it easy to set up and manage campaigns. Integration with tools like Gmail and Pipedrive is seamless.
  • Lemlist: Some users find it less intuitive, especially with advanced features like domain setup and campaign management.
Reply.io-G2-review

Customer Support

  • Reply.io: Known for excellent customer support with fast, effective responses and helpful staff.
  • Lemlist: Mixed experiences with customer support, with some users reporting delays and difficulties.
Reply.io-G2-review
This image shows the user review of Reply.io in G2

Multi-Channel Outreach

  • Reply.io: Supports outreach via email, LinkedIn, SMS, WhatsApp, and phone calls, offering more versatility.
  • Lemlist: Primarily focuses on email outreach and lacks extensive multi-channel capabilities.

AI Capabilities

  • Reply.io: Features Jason AI for crafting personalized emails, responding to prospects, and booking meetings, saving time on email management.
  • Lemlist: Offers personalization but lacks an advanced AI tool like Jason AI.
Reply.io-G2-review
This image shows the user review of Reply.io in G2

In summary, Reply.io excels in ease of use, customer support, multi-channel outreach, and  AI capabilities, making it a more versatile and user-friendly option compared to Lemlist.

Cons of Using Reply.io

  1. Email Deliverability and Campaign Control Issues
    • Users consistently report that email deliverability rates are often inconsistent, which undermines the effectiveness of outreach campaigns. 

Reply.io-G2-review
This image shows the user review of Reply.io in G2
  1. Additionally, there is significant frustration over the limited control users have over campaigns once they have started, making it difficult to manage and optimize ongoing efforts.

Reply.io-G2-review
This image shows the user review of Reply.io in G2
  1. Contact Management: The contact list and synchronization features, especially with tools like HubSpot, could be more robust and faster.

Reply.io-G2-review
This image shows the user review of Reply.io in G2

  1. Pricing and Feature Access: There are complaints about newer ways of increasing prices without prior notice and the need to upgrade subscriptions to access better features.

Reply.io-G2-review
This image shows the user review of Reply.io in G2

  1. Bugs and Glitches: Users have encountered minor bugs or glitches that can affect the overall experience, although the support team is quick to address these issues.

Reply.io-G2-review
This image shows the user review of Reply.io in G2

Reply.io Pricing and Plans

Reply.io offers three main pricing plans for sales engagement, tailored to different needs and scales of operations. 

Reply.io-pricing
This image shows the pricing of Reply.io

Here’s an analysis of these plans:

Monthly Pricing Plans:

  1. Email Volume Plan:
    • Price: $59/month
    • Features:
      • 1,000 active contacts
      • Unlimited mailboxes
      • Unlimited email warmup
      • Unlimited contact storage
      • Unlimited emails monthly
      • 1 user
      • 1,000 data search credits
      • Centralized inbox
      • Anti-spam & deliverability suite
      • Onboarding with the CSM on annual plan

  1. Multichannel Plan:
    • Price: $99 per user/month
    • Features:
      • Unlimited active contacts
      • Multichannel automation
      • 5 mailboxes/user
      • Unlimited email warmup
      • Unlimited contact storage
      • Unlimited emails monthly
      • $ for additional users
      • 1K data search credits
      • Centralized inbox
      • Anti-spam & deliverability suite
      • Onboarding with the CSM on annual plan

  1. Agency Plan:
    • Price: $166/month
    • Features:
      • Unlimited clients
      • Email automation
      • Unlimited mailboxes
      • Unlimited email warmup
      • Unlimited contact storage
      • Unlimited emails monthly
      • Unlimited users & clients
      • 10K data search credits
      • Centralized inbox
      • Anti-spam & deliverability suite
      • Agency dashboard
      • Roles and permissions
      • Dedicated support
      • Unified team workspace
      • Onboarding with the CSM on annual plan

Annual Pricing Plans (Save up to 17%):

  1. Email Volume Plan: $49/month (billed annually)
  2. Multichannel Plan: $89 per user/month (billed annually)
  3. Agency Plan: $166/month (billed annually)

Key Observations:

  • Scalability: The plans are designed to scale with the size and needs of your organization. From small teams needing email automation to large agencies requiring extensive client management and multi-user capabilities.
  • Cost-Efficiency: The annual billing option provides significant savings, making it a cost-effective choice for long-term use.
  • Comprehensive Features: All plans include essential features such as unlimited email warmup, contact storage, and an anti-spam suite, ensuring robust functionality across all tiers.
  • Customization and Flexibility: The plans offer a range of customization options, particularly in the Multichannel and Agency plans, which allow for multichannel automation and additional user functionalities.

This pricing structure makes Reply.io a versatile tool that can cater to different business sizes and outreach needs, providing a balance between cost and functionality.

Comparison Between Lemlist, Salesforge, Instantly and Reply.io

Feature Lemlist Salesforge Instantly Reply.io Recommendations
Pricing (Monthly) Email Starter: $39, Email Pro: $69, Multichannel: $99, Outreach Scale: $159 Standard: $50, Pro: $80, Enterprise: Custom Pricing Growth: $37, Hypergrowth: $97, Light Speed: $358 Email Volume: $59, Multichannel: $99/user, Agency: $166 Choose based on budget and needed features
Contact Management 450M+ leads database, 1-15 sending emails Advanced contact management with smart segments Unlimited email accounts, 1,000-100,000 uploaded contacts Unlimited active contacts, centralized inbox Instantly and Reply.io for higher volume needs
Email Automation AI-generated sequences, customizable campaigns Advanced email sequences, auto-optimization Unlimited email warmup, email campaigns Multichannel automation (email, LinkedIn, phone) Salesforge for advanced personalization
CRM Integration HubSpot, Pipedrive, Salesforce integrations Integration with major CRMs Basic CRM functionalities HubSpot, Pipedrive, Salesforce integrations Salesforge and Reply.io for CRM integration
Multichannel Email, LinkedIn, cold calling Email, LinkedIn, phone Limited to email Email, LinkedIn, phone Reply.io for multichannel campaigns
Support In-app support, dedicated account manager 24/7 support, dedicated success manager Chat support, premium live support 24/7 customer support, onboarding, dedicated account manager Salesforge for comprehensive support
Personalization Custom image personalization, advanced personalization Hyper-personalization features Basic templates Customizable sequences, detailed analytics Salesforge and Reply.io for advanced personalization
Data Features Email finder + verifier, data search credits Advanced data insights, lead scoring Basic data management Email finder + verifier, data search credits Salesforge and Reply.io for extensive data features
Special Features LinkedIn prospection, CRM integration, AI features AI-driven optimizations, smart automation Anti-spam and deliverability suite AI features, LinkedIn prospection, Zapier integration Salesforge and Reply.io for AI and LinkedIn integration

Conclusion: Which Lemlist Alternative Should You Go For?

Key Differences and Similarities

  • Pricing: All platforms offer competitive pricing with various plans tailored to different needs. Instantly offers more flexible contact and email limits, whereas Lemlist and Reply.io have detailed plans focusing on the number of sending emails and multichannel capabilities. Salesforge offers customizable enterprise solutions.

  • Features: Lemlist and Reply.io excel in multichannel capabilities and advanced personalization features. Instantly provides robust email management but lacks some of the advanced features found in Lemlist and Reply.io. Salesforge offers advanced AI-driven optimizations and smart automation.

  • Support: Reply.io and Salesforge offer 24/7 support with dedicated account managers, making them ideal for teams needing comprehensive assistance. Lemlist provides strong in-app support and dedicated account managers as well.

  • Integrations: Salesforge, Reply.io, and Salesforge offer robust CRM integrations (HubSpot, Pipedrive, Salesforce), making them suitable for users needing seamless integration with existing systems.

  • Data Management: Salesforge and Reply.io both provide extensive data management features, including email finders and verifiers, which are essential for detailed outreach campaigns. Salesforge also offers advanced data insights and lead scoring.

Recommendations for Different User Types

  • Small to Medium Businesses: Instantly and Salesforge for budget-friendly options with flexible contact and email limits.

  • Sales Teams and Agencies: Reply.io for comprehensive multichannel campaigns, advanced analytics, and dedicated support.

  • Personalized Campaigns: Salesforge for advanced personalization, AI-generated sequences, and extensive CRM integrations.

  • High Volume Needs: Instantly for higher contact and email limits with competitive pricing.

  • AI-Driven Optimization: Salesforge for advanced AI-driven optimizations, smart automation, and lead scoring.

Ultimately, your choice will depend on your specific requirements, budget, and the features most critical to your outreach strategy.

Happy prospecting, and may your sales quotas be ever in your favor!

Lukas Makšimas
Senior Account Executive